To the Members of Cincinnati City Council,
Cincinnati has a graffiti problem. But it also has an opportunity.
As City Council moves to strengthen graffiti removal efforts, I encourage our elected leaders to consider an important distinction: Not every painted wall is a problem that needs solving. Sometimes, it's a piece of culture worth preserving.
Let's be clear: Nobody is arguing that property owners should have to tolerate unwanted vandalism, offensive markings, or damage to their buildings. Cincinnati deserves clean, welcoming, well-maintained public spaces. But there's a difference between cleaning up our city and scrubbing away its personality.
Graffiti and street art have long been forms of creative expression. At their best, they transform neglected spaces into unexpected galleries, give emerging artists a public canvas, and contribute to the visual identities of neighborhoods.
Some works demonstrate extraordinary artistic skill. Others communicate something meaningful about the communities in which they appear. And some simply make an otherwise ordinary walk through Cincinnati a little more interesting.
Why should we automatically assume that a blank concrete wall is better than a beautifully painted one?
I believe Cincinnati can pursue graffiti removal while also embracing the creative potential of its urban landscape.
Here are five ideas worth considering:
Distinguish vandalism from artistic value. Develop clear guidelines for identifying noteworthy street art, with input from artists, residents, property owners, and neighborhood organizations.
Create a street art preservation process. Before removing substantial or artistically significant works, provide an opportunity to evaluate whether they merit preservation, where legally and practically feasible.
Designate legal graffiti walls. Give artists legitimate, accessible spaces to practice, experiment, collaborate, and contribute to Cincinnati's visual culture.
Turn neglected infrastructure into creative opportunities. Explore partnerships that transform underpasses, retaining walls, and other appropriate public spaces into rotating showcases for local artists.
Celebrate Cincinnati's street art. Develop a public-facing map or digital gallery highlighting notable works, the artists behind them, and the neighborhoods they enrich.
These ideas need not undermine property rights or the city's legitimate interest in preventing vandalism. In fact, thoughtful partnerships with artists and property owners could help Cincinnati distinguish between unwanted markings and creative work that communities genuinely value.
As a designer and educator, I believe some of the most interesting opportunities for improving a city emerge when we challenge the assumptions behind a problem.
The question shouldn't simply be, "How do we remove more graffiti?" It should also be, "What is worth preserving, and how can we create more opportunities for art?"
Cincinnati is a city with a remarkable creative community. Our streets, walls, bridges, and public spaces help tell its story. Let's maintain them responsibly without assuming that every unconventional expression of creativity is an eyesore.
A cleaner Cincinnati and a more creative Cincinnati do not have to be competing visions.
We can have both.
Sincerely,
Bennett Nestok
Founder, Rethink Cincy!
#SavePublicArt #GraffitiEnthusiast #Cincinnati #RethinkCincy